I would go with an EVO, but honestly do you want to drive any of those nice cars in the winter? maybe you should keep the 16 yr old DSM just for like a winter beater.
If thats the case I would go for M3 four door as a nice daily. You can find them in Cleveland/Cincy at the 2 big dealerships there for around 19-25 with low miles.
The g35 over the 350z just for luxury purpose.
Fuck jag they blow (opinion of mine)
Audi TTs,Benz are nice cars but I dont fine them confortable at all.
IS300-beautiful car and very comfortable. A lot of switches inside to play with though so hope you like that.
good luck