1 series BMWs are retarded. true story. For the price a 335i would be the better choice. The problem is the 1 is way to close in every category to the 3 series and doesn't merit it's hefty price tag. And they absolutely do not hold their value, mabye a bit better than the Mustang but probably only margionally. A guy down the street has been trying to sell a white one for about 9 months now. From what I've read, the new Mustang is actually a very well balanced car. The front end feel is supposed to be stellar and on par with BMW which is supposed to have the best steering feel on the market. Only problem I would have is the solid rear axle, but that is also supposed to be well tuned and makes for a very well balanced chassis. That being said, Mustang convertables conjure up pictures of blond girls, not grown men, and $41k!?