Have shot both in 9mm ... both are as accurate as you can shoot them. Like what was said previously, if it doesn't fit your hand, you won't shoot for shit no matter the name on the gun or the price of it. If you know someone that has one or can rent one and test out a holster to see how it rides on your frame, could make the final decision for you. Although heavier than the polymer pistols, I love my Sig P239. Like the way heavier pistols shoot.