Psh, that chevy guy talks out of his ass. But like Jags said, carry what you are comfortable with. Just like bikes, everyone has there preference. Although you can't usually take a concealed carry test drive so that makes it difficult. Like Max Power says, he loves his. I have never carried one concealed so obviously I am going to be biased. I only speak from my usage of them while at the range and such. Of course, I also love my M&P too much that I really can't see liking anything else, especially a revolver, as a daily carry. Regardless of what you carry, and you said you already have your CHL, my opinion is a both a revolver and semi auto are better to carry than nothing at all. If the only gun I has was a revolver, I'd carry it in a heartbeat. To each there own. Good luck on whatever route you decide on.