ok...
Heres the scoop.
Metro Fitness is in hot water right now so i would stay as far away as possible.
Urban Active is not a bad company if you know who you are dealing with. I Ran the personal training dept at the grove city location for a long time. It all depends on who you deal with and at what club.
New Albany is one of the better clubs, talk to Steve or ask for christine. Tell them i refered you.
Power shack is the best gym in the columbus market, phil ( owner) is customer service driven and they deliver a very good product. ( if you can get over the selection of music.) Go to westerville ask for vernon and tell them i referred you. He works m-thurs 12-5, vernon is the district manager.He will give you my referral price, which is low as hell.
Fitness 19, i havent done anything with this company but its hard to beat $12 a month.
Overall for what the power shack offers you at the price i can get you in there for. The customer service and atmosphere, there is no better gym out there.