I like the General Grabber AT2s...seems like a slightly softer BFG KO with better sidewall. Goodyear Duratracs are the best all around all-season that look absolutely killer to boot. You can get the Goodyear Authoritys at Wally World which are just a cheaper similar version (also probably just P-metric weight ratings). The Falken Rocky Mountain ATS / Wildpeak AT are also VERY good tires for the money. If you like the KOs, and want to spend the cash, they are coming out with a KO2...pretty much the same center tread, but with different outer lugs. These recommendations are with offroading in mind, but still good for Ohio street/snow (the GY or Falkens specifically).
http://www.walmart.com/msharbor/ip/Goodyear-Wrangler-Authority-Tire-31X10.50R15LT/11983156