Little update... Just pulled the wheels off the car, and all 4 rotors spun by hand just fine. I figured maybe it just had something to do with the cold weather and the issue was fixed.
Put each wheel back on very slowly and triple checked to make sure that nothing was rubbing or touching. Got all 4 back on, started the car, and one is stuck again. I should have just put the old wheels back on.. My own fault.
Going to try the old wheels tomorrow and see if that fixes it.