What I'm seeing in this thread are two kinds of people: Those who don't like smoking but feel the need for liberty to be upheld, and selfish, ignorant people who think that only their opinion matters. What you guys don't realize is that this is taking a huge chunk out of that little thing we like to call "free enterprise"... telling business owners that their patrons aren't allowed to do something legal within their establishment? Are you people real? that's an absolutely incredible abuse of the Bill of Rights, and you guys are ignoring it because the decisions upports your cause. WHat if somebody passed a law that said you weren't allowed to have a car or vehicle that could go over X miles per hour or couldn't have more than X horsepower, because such a vehicle would pollute the environment excessively... what would you say then? You people need to open your eyes and realize some of the shit that goes on, and how it affects the nation or populace as a whole, not just how it affects you.