i was sorta in the same boat as you. my record isnt great, but luckily a few things have dropped off, and in the last 3 years, all i have on my record is 1 at fault accident and a comp claim over $1,000. i checked a couple places, and i ended up going with progressive. for me being 21, full coverage (due to loan) on a 1995 acura integra gsr (2dr) im paying 210/mo. seems like a lot, but i was paying 180 on a 2003 elantra base model. i was thinking it would be more for the integra, so when i saw a 30$ increase, i jumped on it
and they got me my paperwork in the mail within about 5 days
http://www.progressive.com