I, on the other hand, feel that he made some good points when talking to Rick and pointing out the consequences when he failed to act. Though, I do agree that Rick should beat his ass for talking back to him.
That character needed shot. You attack me in a situation like they are in, and you're dead; surrender or not. I'd have also hunted down the .gov prior to allowing them to raid the prison. The best defense is total annihilation of the offense. :fuckyeah:
Hershel is a Bible-thumping cripple. No room for his nice-guy mentality in a post-apocalyptic world. If it came down to it, he'd be the first I'd turn into walker-bait if I had the need.