I think an important issue specifically regarding "carry" threads is that regardless of how you feel about a particular firearm, handling it, or even shooting it, isn't the same as having that chunk of metal/polymer on your person all the time, in different positions or places easily accessible. So hearing personal anecdotes helps whittle down the list, since its not always practical to borrow a bunch of different firearms for a few days.
For instance I love the G19, but don't care for how it conceals. On me, it leaves a noticeable print in almost all of my normal positions (jeans and a T-shirt, no jacket) and would obviously serve poorly for pocket carry. At the same time I absolutely hate shooting my LCP, but carry it almost as much as the P938, and if I'm wearing business or even business casual it's the only real choice I have. While the Sig is pocketable I find it a bit too heavy for slacks, and while I adore my N82 Tactical holster, the visible clip is still a no-no for me.
So I suppose I'm saying don't limit your choices to a strict list, or a single EDC. Carry what you can, on a need by need basis, and don't overthink the small details, we're already in the realm of the vastly improbable.