I've gotten 2 estimates so far. I still have a couple more guys coming out this Saturday to give a couple more estimates. However, I think I already know who I'm going to use, but we'll see.
The first guy that came out said he would need 3 - 4 days to complete the project and it would cost $795. He said that he would need to take a scrap piece of drywall and practice on it for a while to get a consistency and texture that comes as close as possible to what's currently on the ceiling. I can't take that much time off work for this project, so I'm not going to use this guy for sure.
The second guy that came out said it would take about 4 hours and cost $200. He really seemed to know what he is doing. He has been doing this work for a little over 30 years and said he has a lot of brushes and could match it up really well. He said just by looking at it, he knows exactly which brush he would use to match it up. This guy can do it on a Saturday, which is awesome since I work M-F.
We'll see what the other 2 guys have to say before I make my final decision.