I have to totally agree, I really enjoy both and feel that it really takes two cars to acheive those sensations. My Camaro is great at neck snapping, but if it handled well the hit you in the ass feel wouldn't be as dramatic. Same thing with my Miata, if it was fast then the handlingwouldn't stand out as much. Someday I'll have a car to do both, but I really like switching between the two.
Its so much fun getting back into the other car because its such a different feel. I wish more people would learn to appreciate the differences, but of course a year ago I wouldn't have seen the appeal in the BRZ either.