Kingy's Pizza is amazing, it's my favorite by far. It's about a 15min drive and totally worth it.
Papa John's BBQ chicken pizza is my second favorite but their other pizzas/toppings are about average.
Donato's is good if you have the munchies but I can really only eat their pepporoni pizzas.
Romeo's is convenient because it's close and they're the only ones I know of who have an optional gluten-free crust (for the gf)
One last thing, anyone who calls pizza a "pie" is a wannabe italian hipster faggot. Pie is pie, pizza is pizza.