I think the 5th gens look aight. Def don't like the 6th gens. Wish they'd have gone for more of a first gen look myself. The numbers don't lie on performance so it's hard to argue that, but among the 4 biggest "throwbacks" (Mustang, Camaro, Charger, Challenger) of the last decade or so I'd say, overall, the Mustang and the Challenger landed a bit closer to home in terms of retro styling nods.
Performance wise? Ferd uses bicycle tires and can't get power to the ground thus taking out crowds and Doge made some whales. Powerful whales, but imagine if they had performance in mind and kept the size and weight at bay. Cheby takes the W.
..."Charger" lol.