Have you owned a coupe before? I've never seen any of my friends go from a coupe, to a 4 door, and back to a coupe (as their only car). Those 2 extra doors are just that more convenient. I'm a sedan/ wagon guy myself.
A4 Avant (Wagon)
CTS-V Wagon
EG Hatch (Hatchback, cheap and cheap to fix, but old.)
Beetle (Gay but its wheelbase is pretty short!)
GTI/ Golf (This is a serious suggestion, comes in 4 and 2 doors)
Veloster
Focus ST
Fiesta
Mazda 3 5-door
Kia Forte
Fiat 500