Yeah, I got a pair from the wife for xmas. Seem like good quality, anodized aluminum construction, the ball joint is nice and tight, mirror looks optically as good as anything I've seen oem. Granted, they have not yet suffered the slings and arrows of 11k rpm and 120 mph yet, so they could be shit masquerading as shinola, but based on appearance I'm calling them good. At least with these you deal directly with the supplier, should make refund/return easier if they're junk. I will say that one of mine arrived damaged and we complained. They sent a replacement after a brief hassle that culminated with me lambasting them on their Facebook page. They then went after DHL for the cost.