iPod > Everything Else
Seriously, the iPod is so easy to use. I wouldn't even think about the Dell DJ. I've also had my iPod for 3 years, and I have no battery problems whatsoever. And we're talking a second-gen iPod, the one that was supposed to have all the battery issues. In the case of MP3 players, you get what you pay for. I also use the iTunes music store quite frequently, and all I have to do is plug the iPod into the laptop and update is done in 30 seconds or less for 4 full CDs. If what you're also looking for is an external HDD, you can't beat the new 60 GB photo iPod for $569 w/ student discount. The new photo iPods also have a video out which is kinda cool, and more battery life.