Well after about an 1/2 hour of messing with all the phones, I decided to go with the voyager. I really like the ops, keys, and size of the phone. This will be my first non-flip phone in a long time.
I hear you on the scratch resistance and I just ordered a full phone protector from http://www.zagg.com. The invisibleSHIELD is a really thin and has a life time warranty. It is used to protect cell phones, laptops, cameras, GPS units or just about any electronic gadget you want. I have a 20% off discount code if anyone is interested?