Troy Smith (Heisman year):
Comp - 203
Att - 311
Pct - 65.3
Yrds - 2542
Y/A - 8.2
TD - 30
Int - 6
QBR - 161.9
Rushing:
Att - 72
Yards - 204
Avg - 2.8
TD - 1
Braxton Miller (20130):
Comp - 162
Att - 255
Pct - 63.5
Yrds - 2094
Y/A - 8.2
TD - 24
Int - 7
QBR - 158.1
Rushing:
Att - 171
Yards - 1068
Avg - 6.2
TD - 12
Pretty close pass pct, y/a is identical, Smith had ~500 more passing yards but ~800 less rushing yards. Smith had 6 more passing TDs but 11 less rushing TDs. Miller had just 1 more INT. QBR is only 3 points apart. Rushing goes to Braxton by a landslide.
If you call Smith OSU's standard for stellar QB's, Braxton is right there with him in the stats, or arguably better. You don't have to like him, but numbers don't lie. Miller has 1 more turn over but accounted for 5 more TD's and does much more on his feet whether it's a designed run or a scramble, all without sacrificing as much as people imply with his arm.