Damn. Good luck with insurance.
I agree though, I don't feel as safe as I used to either.
We live in Bexley, a nice quiet neighborhood as well and both our cars got stuff stolen from them, luckily the theives were nice enough not to break anything.
The next week I went out and bought a handgun, a shotgun is next on my list.
I hate the feeling of the unknown, I honestly have not slept very well in the past month or so and I blame this theft as a leading reason, its the first time I've ever had anything stolen, and to know that the people were THAT close to me/my home is SCARY. Especially with two young kids.
Good luck and do what you have to. Bexley PD stepped up patrol around my area/block after I notified them, hopefully Grove City will too.