Good points other then it took a questionable call to get the game even into overtime! It was the right call but was still questionable.
Notre Dame got into that game by default due to them having 9 wins, which at the time was an automatic bid for them. And OSU's offense was explosive that year with Ginn, Gonzo, Pittman and Smith..so theres the good offense over good D argument.
Kansas state still put up 28 against OSU who returned just about everyone on D from the NC team and only lost by 7.
Penn State played the entire 2nd half and some of the 2nd quarter without their starting QB!! Thats the thing people dont realize, plus you gotta question just how good Penn State really is when you look at their schedule they havent really played anyone besides the Bucks.
Again i'll take a great offense over a great D any day of the week.