Try something different: Black lip, White spokes. Or Black lip, Red stripe, White Spokes.
As for the rest of the car, do you know if the headlights are held together with a sealer goop? If so, you can probably bake them, take them apart, and paint some of the chrome in there black. It's a popular mod in the Subaru community and looks great.
You'd also likely be able to remove those orange reflectors and replace the bulbs with amber LEDs.