If you are the original owners you may look to see if your roofing materials are under warranty. The way it was explained to me is as long as the roof is put on correctly, the materials carry the warranty, not the company that installed them.
We used B&T who also had good reviews on Angie's list. The roof got done and folks were nice but the scheduling got a little screwy. Stay away from Roofing Plus if they are still in business. Benchmark is another company that is supposed to have a good rep. They did my neighbors roof. The only issue they had was the crew hit the garage with their trailer. But they did repair it. Good luck.