WTG Ben!! My wife and I did the same thing. We have a 2 story "cookie cutter" home right outside Westerville (1 mile from my frisbee golf course and 2 miles from that courses daddy, SpaceGhost) and we absolutely LOVE IT!
Think of it this way:
Its a home. Its yours. And families have been raised in smaller places with no problems whatsoever. Who cares what others say, its your money so do with it what you want!
M/I actually has fairly high build quality. For the style home that Stephanie and I purchased, they are rated much higher than Dominion and all the others for customer satisfaction.
M/I was an easy choice for me. I walked in and said I am putting this much down, I want my payments to be this, show me my options, and they did. NONE! of the other companies did that for me, they all tried to upsell us to something that we did not want.
I was raised in a place where it took 10 minutes to get to town and our neighbors were more than 100 yards away, and personally growing up in that shit SUCKS! Talk about maladjusted children!! I feel its best to live in a neighborhood with other children and families close to your age so that YOUR kids can grow up without social disorders.
Cudos to you and best of luck in the future!! :thumbup: