Donatos
Massey's
Capuanos
Grapevine
Pizza Shack
Little Sicily's
Notice anything about these? I have lived in Columbus for four months and these are all the SAME GOD DAMN PIZZA. Aside of a major chain (PJ, Dominos, PH), the thin crust tiny pepperoni setup is the only thing I can find up here.
My vote is for Hometown Pizza in Minford, OH.