Pretty close.
Sometimes I would call ahead though, they blow through their handguns pretty fast there. Plus if you call Buckeye, you don't sit on hold forever waiting for someone to decide it's time for them to see if there are any calls waiting. Also, half the time I've been helped at Buckeye, I haven't even had to take a number, whereas at Vance's, even if they are slow, you have to take a # and wait for them to call your #.
I find the staff overall just more enjoyable than Vance's.