I recommend The Cake Studio for the cake.
We loved ours.
We didn't have good luck with our photographer, and had the ceremony/reception at Tall Timbers in Reynoldsburg. Tall Timbers was great, good food etc. Its nothing fancy, but nice enough for us.
Agreed black00ws6, the food was a bit pricey, but very good. Being able to bring your own alcohol was a BIG cost saver.