Hellcat is the better bang for the buck if you want to be seen as the high class Redneck. The CTS-V is the real deal. That said, I'd take either but would really depend on what the deals are like. I was on Long Island a couple weeks back and saw a Hellcat Charger at a $20k premium over MSRP. For that money, I'd go Caddy. I've yet to drive the new Caddy but am afraid if I do, I'm going to be giving he wife the S4 and trading her van in on a V. Must. wait. for. a. couple. years..........