I had John Schreck at Dent Magic on Sawmill take care of a door ding last year. Absolutely flawless.
My car is currently at CSN Motorsports in Plain City (up off Post Road) to get my door fixed after a hit and run. Charley has been awesome to work with. I went up for a quote and got a nice little tour of his place. They had a new SLR in there that they were making all the interior panels out of Carbon Fiber. Also a few Porches getting body work. Seems to really know his stuff, so he got the job. I had taken it to 4 others as well for quotes and insight, but they didnt seem very good in comparison.