Sorry, twas hit with the banhamer (obama_fried_chicken.jpg Phill u mad :gabe:) At any rate no, the successes are not false, but keep in mind there is a learning curve to anything aqua, alot of those guys are probably pros and have learned how to keep bacteria/fungi at bay. When your first starting off it's a good idea to stay away from organic nutrients untill you get a handle on things (primarily the specs of your setup, I.E. how cool it will run, how adequate the ventilation is etc.). Once you've had a couple successful grows under your belt with chemical nutes then is the time to probably switch over and try something organic.