I had my car repaired last year at Rife's in Westerville. They did a good job initially, however the rear fender developed a big spot of rust on the lip where they taped it off and it let moisture in, causing about 4 inches or so of rust. Thankfully I noticed it.
Now, they did repair it without any issue, covered a rental and were very apologetic the whole time, but still makes me a little leery of their work. Plus I reviewed my dash cam after the fact and their painter had some not nice things to say about having to fix his screw up.
Like Tom said above, it's a crap shoot. Any time I've had to have a car repaired, there has always been an issue(s) after the fact. Just find a shop that you know will stand behind their work.