Can't speak to either of them, as I've been going to Westerville Athletic ever since I moved here. Great hours, equip is always kept in good shape, staff's helpful, and they've got a pool I can do proper turns in. My only gripes are that they could use a bigger parking lot (especially during the "New Years Resolution" boom), and the pool is usually a little too warm for my tastes (84 is great for kids playing, but for working out, 80 is better, and 76-78 prime).