^^ This.
First, file a police report, get the vid from the gas station and see who it was. It's likely they have cameras outside too so if he went through it there you might just get lucky on that.
Bring the police report the club and ask them if they have cameras. Chances are they do. I know the Dublin Rec. Ctr does and they even post that you're being watched. If they do, ask to see them or do what you need to in order to make that happen. Even their parking lot cameras
Personally, 1/5 and potentially others doesn't give me a good feeling that you really "know" who did it. I'm all for confronting them, but you have to make sure you know for certain.
Cliffs:
Camera's, they are everywhere. Exhaust those possibilities.