+1. Came here to post this. It's deelicious...and the one in Upper Arlington just down the street from Kahoots on Kenny Road by Henderson. :ninja:
The other option on Wednesday evenings is Morone's on Bethel Road: they have an italian buffet that includes PIZZA, pastas, and salads as well, with dessert pizza and brownies. Does not include soda. Very good and kid-friendly as well. It's in the plaza with BW3's, Texas Roadhouse, Hockey Stop, etc...
Understood you are moving to Polaris, but both are just minutes off of 315 on Bethel and Henderson exits.
EDIT: Why is Cici's shutting down everywhere? It seemed to be a great model. If costs were a concern, they could've upped the price and I still would've gone with my family.