Agree but wanted to add one thing. Views expressed in my response do not reflect those initially broadcast by Tilley.
I'd be furious if I was FSU and running undefeated and hanging on to 3rd place by the skin on my teeth. The wins have been marginal, and ugly. But alas, still the only undefeated team. They should be without a doubt #1. But then the undefeated TCU's and Boise's of the future will have that claim also.
I think that alone shows the playoff committee's dysfunction.